Hope Ranch Height Restriction Ruled Unenforceable

Judge Donna Geck Rules That an 85-Year-Old Property Deed Is Not Valid

Hope Ranch | Credit: Wikimedia

Mon Dec 23, 2024 | 01:12pm

This article was underwritten in part by the Mickey Flacks Journalism Fund for Social Justice, a proud, innovative supporter of local news. To make a contribution go to sbcan.org/journalism_fund.


Santa Barbara County’s superior court has ruled that a nearly 85-year height restriction on a property in Hope Ranch is unenforceable. 

The decision comes after a civil suit between Hope Ranch residents Max Liskin and Marc and Pauline Lowe, Liskin’s neighbors who sought to waive a 1940 deed on their property that would have restricted any home they built to a single story. The court’s decision states that the one-story restriction is not a general restriction and other properties in the area with single-story height restriction deeds had multi-story homes. It also states that the one-story restriction is not necessary to protect Hope Ranch’s views, privacy, or rural character. 

Liskin’s initial complaint also charged HOA members and the association with a breach of fiduciary duties and fraudulent concealment, citing how the members and the association initially attempted to waive the deed. These parties settled earlier this year. 

More like this

Exit mobile version